What the AI manuscript review checks
- Numbers that disagree. Abstract vs results, tables vs text, counts and percentages that don't add up.
- Statistics checked. Percentages, counts and the P values and confidence intervals that go with them are checked for internal consistency, and the report shows the arithmetic.
- References. Each PMID or DOI is checked in PubMed and Crossref: does it point to the right paper, do the authors, title and year match, and has it been retracted?
- Reviewer-style comments. Contradictions and conclusions stronger than the evidence, listed separately from hard errors.
- A second read. A second AI model reads the manuscript independently, and the report shows which findings both reviews raised.
You get one PDF. The first page tells you what to fix first; the rest lists each finding with the passage it refers to and what it was checked against.
See a sample report
This is a real report on version 1 of a paper published openly on F1000Research (Susanty et al., 2026, CC BY). Over two rounds of open peer review, the journal's reviewers pointed out eight errors that were already present in version 1, and the authors corrected them in later versions. The report on version 1 lists all eight, including:
- the prevalence for women and men in the abstract (31.2% and 25.6%) does not match Table 1 (34.4% and 26.1%);
- Table 2 starts from 5,366 participants, while the study analysed 7,147;
- age odds ratios of 0.008 and 0.002 next to confidence intervals around 1;
- citations in the introduction whose cited papers are not about the claim being made.
We chose this paper because its reviews and corrections are public, so you can compare the report with what the reviewers found. The check was run once, as a customer's would be, with nothing tuned for this paper.

How it works
- Pay $49 securely with Stripe.
- Upload your manuscript as a Word file (.docx, up to 25 MB), with tables and references in the same file, within 30 days of payment. The upload link appears after payment and is also emailed to you.
- Usually within 2 business days (Monday to Friday, UK time), we email you the report as a PDF from [email protected].
Made for English research manuscripts in medicine and the life sciences, up to 10,000 words of main text and 100 references. Longer manuscript or another format? Email contact@medicrab.com and we'll let you know.
Revising after peer review? Send the revised version. The report shows whether the revised numbers agree across the abstract, text and tables.
Your manuscript stays confidential
- Only the person running your check opens it. One member of our team sets up the check and sends you the report.
- Never used for training. The check uses GPT models on Microsoft Azure and Claude models from Anthropic, and each provider commits not to train on this content. We don't train on it or sell it either.
- Deleted within 14 days. We delete your uploaded file 14 days after upload, and our working copy and the report no later than 14 days after we send it.
- Please remove patient identifiers such as names and record numbers before uploading.
Details, including how long model providers may keep requests for abuse monitoring, are in our privacy policy.
Which option fits you
| Option | Best for | Price |
|---|---|---|
| AI manuscript review (this page) | A thorough check before you submit or resubmit, without installing anything | $49 per manuscript, report usually within 2 business days |
| MediCrab desktop app | Checking again and again while you revise, on your own computer | Free with your own ChatGPT or Claude subscription or API key; Plus from $20/month |
| Human pre-submission review | Expert comments on study design, novelty and journal fit | Usually a few hundred dollars and several days; for example, Editage lists $200 with a 5-day turnaround |
Prices checked 9 November 2026.
Questions
Is this peer review?
No. It checks for the kinds of errors reviewers notice (numbers, statistics, references and overreaching claims) so you can fix them first. It does not judge novelty or predict whether a journal will accept your paper.
Does a person read my manuscript?
Yes, one person: the member of our team who runs the check opens your manuscript and reads the report before sending it. The findings come from MediCrab's AI review and are not checked line by line by a specialist in your field.
How long does it take?
Usually within 2 business days of uploading (Monday to Friday, UK time). If you replace the file, the time starts again from the new upload.
What if it finds nothing?
Then the report says so and shows what was checked, such as which references were confirmed and how many citations were compared with their sources. That is worth knowing before you submit, too.
Can I get a refund?
You can cancel for a full refund any time before we start your check, and if we don't send your report we refund you in full. If the report is wrong because of our mistake, such as checking the wrong file, tell us within 14 days of receiving it and we will correct it, or refund you if we can't. Once the report has been sent, the fee is otherwise non-refundable. The full service terms are part of our Terms of Service.
Can I use it for a revision?
Yes, as a new order. Each order covers one report on one version of one manuscript. If you replace the file before we send your report, we check the new file instead.
Does it read the full text of the papers I cite?
Where an open full text can be retrieved, it searches that text for the passages that relate to your sentence. Otherwise it works from the abstract and the bibliographic record, and checks of whether a paper supports your sentence are more limited.
Do I need to disclose that I used AI?
Follow your target journal's policy; many ask authors to describe any AI use. The email with your report names the models that were used.
I'm a peer reviewer. Can I send a manuscript I'm reviewing?
No. Manuscripts under review are confidential, and journals set their own rules on reviewers using AI. We only accept manuscripts from their authors.
Which files can I send?
A Word file (.docx, up to 25 MB) with the tables and reference list in the same file. If your file is larger, email contact@medicrab.com first.
Beta